nfl-draft.jpg
Getty Images

It’s draft week, which means I have two more mock drafts to unveil before it all becomes official. First up, I’m repackaging an idea from Pete Prisco, who has been doing a “What I think NFL teams should do” mock draft for years.

I love this idea because it gets you on the record and gives fans an easy way to point out where you were criminally wrong (or maybe even right!). In case you’re wondering, here are my “What Teams Should Do” mock drafts for 2025, 2024 and 2023.

A few more notes:

1. If you’re looking to kill time between now and the start of the actual draft, we rolled out our annual live seven-round mock draft on “With the First Pick,” the NFL Draft podcast I co-host alongside former Titans GM Ran Carthon. We didn’t tackle it alone — colleagues Pete Prisco, Bryant McFadden, Leger Douzable, Mike Renner, Emory Hunt, Josh Edwards and JP Acosta joined us as we worked through all 257 picks. 

2. Check back this Wednesday for my final mock draft of the 2026 draft season, where I’ll predict all 32 selections … and likely overthink every one of them.

So here it is: what I think NFL teams should do during the first round of the draft.

The 2026 NFL Draft will take place Thursday through Saturday in Pittsburgh. You can find more draft coverage at CBSSports.com, including weekly mock drafts and regular evaluations of the top prospects.

NFL Mock Draft
Round 1
Round 1 – Pick 1

Fernando Mendoza


QB

Indiana

• Jr

• 6’5″

/ 236 lbs

Projected Team

Las Vegas

PROSPECT RNK

1st

POSITION RNK

1st

PAYDS

3535

RUYDS

276

INTS

6

TDS

48

The Raiders shouldn’t overthink this. Don’t even answer the phone. Take Mendoza and move on.

Round 1 – Pick 2

David Bailey


EDGE

Texas Tech

• Sr

• 6’4″

/ 250 lbs

Projected Team

N.Y. Jets

PROSPECT RNK

20th

POSITION RNK

3rd

Here’s the thing: Is Bailey in the same class as Abdul Carter or Will Anderson Jr., the No. 3 overall picks in 2025 and 2023? No. But that doesn’t mean he isn’t one of the best players in the 2026 class — and he’s certainly more of a sure bet as an edge rusher than Arvell Reese. Aaron Glenn could have months — not years — to right the ship, and Bailey makes the most sense with that in mind.

Round 1 – Pick 3

Arvell Reese


EDGE

Ohio State

• Jr

• 6’4″

/ 243 lbs

Projected Team

Arizona

PROSPECT RNK

3rd

POSITION RNK

2nd

The Cardinals have taken a defensive lineman in the first round of each of the past two drafts, but they still need an explosive playmaker off the edge. Reese’s versatility, coupled with his freakish athleticism, makes him a good fit here. I also considered Francis Mauigoa, but there will likely still be starting-caliber right tackles available at the top of Round 2.

Round 1 – Pick 4

Sonny Styles


LB

Ohio State

• Sr

• 6’5″

/ 243 lbs

Projected Team

Tennessee

PROSPECT RNK

9th

POSITION RNK

1st

I continue to go back and forth on this. I think Jeremiyah Love would have a bigger impact on this team in Year 1, but I also believe Sonny Styles could be a bigger, faster Fred Warner. And if we’re redrafting Warner’s class, he’s an easy top-10 pick. By the way, do you know who was in San Francisco when the 49ers took Warner? Robert Saleh.

Round 1 – Pick 5

Francis Mauigoa


OT

Miami (Fla.)

• Jr

• 6’6″

/ 329 lbs

Projected Team

N.Y. Giants

PROSPECT RNK

16th

POSITION RNK

4th

I’m sure Giants fans are throwing things at their screens as they read this, and even if you’re worried about Cam Skattebo’s ability to stay healthy, I’m more concerned about Jaxson Dart’s health with this pick. Jeremiyah Love would be fun, but he’s not a huge need. You know what is? Right guard. And Mauigoa, who I think is an NFL starting RT, could slide inside for now — unless you think Evan Neal and/or Daniel Faalele is a fine option instead.

Round 1 – Pick 6

Caleb Lomu


OT

Utah

• Soph

• 6’6″

/ 308 lbs

Projected Team

Cleveland

PROSPECT RNK

13th

POSITION RNK

3rd

Lomu is my highest-rated left tackle. And while Kadyn Proctor would seem like a no-brainer selection here, there are concerns about both his weight and his focus from one play to the next. Lomu needs to get stronger, but he’s a high-end athlete for the position who just turned 21.

Round 1 – Pick 7

Jeremiyah Love


RB

Notre Dame

• Jr

• 6’0″

/ 214 lbs

Projected Team

Washington

PROSPECT RNK

7th

POSITION RNK

1st

RUYDS

1372

YDS/ATT

6.9

REYDS

280

TDS

21

The Commanders could go wide receiver or edge rusher here, but Love not only fills a need in the backfield, he’s a receiving threat, too. I love the idea of pairing him with Jayden Daniels in the backfield.

Round 1 – Pick 8

Mansoor Delane


CB

LSU

• Sr

• 6’0″

/ 187 lbs

Projected Team

New Orleans

PROSPECT RNK

14th

POSITION RNK

3rd

In recent drafts, the Saints have prioritized the offensive and defensive lines and typically targeted defensive backs on Day 2. But after letting Alontae Taylor walk in free agency — and even with the emergence of Quincy Riley — there is a glaring need at outside CB opposite Kool-Aid McKinstry. Delane is the best corner in this class, this is around the range where he’ll likely come off the board, and there’s a better chance of finding an edge rusher, safety or wide receiver at pick No. 42 who can contribute right away than hoping a CB is still on the board there.

Round 1 – Pick 9

Caleb Downs


S

Ohio State

• Jr

• 6’0″

/ 205 lbs

Projected Team

Kansas City

PROSPECT RNK

8th

POSITION RNK

1st

Downs’ defensive coordinator at Ohio State, Matt Patricia, described him as a “defensive eraser.” That’s probably underselling Downs’ impact. Either way, the Chiefs lost a lot of their secondary this offseason, and while pass rusher is also a need, Downs is a special talent.

  From

Cincinnati Bengals

Round 1 – Pick 10

Carnell Tate


WR

Ohio State

• Jr

• 6’2″

/ 192 lbs

Projected Team

N.Y. Giants

PROSPECT RNK

18th

POSITION RNK

3rd

REC

51

REYDS

875

YDS/REC

17.2

TDS

9

The Giants bolstered the offensive line at No. 5, and here they get Malik Nabers a running mate and Jaxson Dart another big-play weapon.

Round 1 – Pick 11

Jordyn Tyson


WR

Arizona State

• Jr

• 6’2″

/ 203 lbs

Projected Team

Miami

PROSPECT RNK

23rd

POSITION RNK

5th

REC

61

REYDS

711

YDS/REC

11.7

TDS

9

The Dolphins have needs on both sides of the ball, but with Tyson looking the part at his private workout last week, he’ll have a chance to be a top-15 pick.

Round 1 – Pick 12

Rueben Bain Jr.


EDGE

Miami (Fla.)

• Jr

• 6’2″

/ 263 lbs

Projected Team

Dallas

PROSPECT RNK

2nd

POSITION RNK

1st

With the Bengals trading for Dexter Lawrence, Bain slips past 10 and lands here, right in the Cowboys’ lap.

Round 1 – Pick 13

Makai Lemon


WR

USC

• Jr

• 5’11”

/ 192 lbs

Projected Team

L.A. Rams

PROSPECT RNK

17th

POSITION RNK

2nd

REC

79

REYDS

1156

YDS/REC

14.6

TDS

13

Davante Adams and Puka Nacua both have contracts that expire after the 2026 season. Even if (when) that changes, adding Makai Lemon to an already explosive offense makes a lot of sense here.

Round 1 – Pick 14

Olaivavega Ioane


IOL

Penn State

• Jr

• 6’4″

/ 323 lbs

Projected Team

Baltimore

PROSPECT RNK

15th

POSITION RNK

1st

I considered taking Ioane at No. 11 — and there’s a chance he goes higher than that Thursday — but this is a best-case scenario for the Ravens. Ioane is the cleanest prospect in the class.

Round 1 – Pick 15

Akheem Mesidor


EDGE

Miami (Fla.)

• Sr

• 6’3″

/ 259 lbs

Projected Team

Tampa Bay

PROSPECT RNK

30th

POSITION RNK

4th

Yes, Mesidor is 25, but the bigger concern is his injury history. If teams clear him medically, he’s a first-round talent and would fill an obvious need in Tampa.

  From

Indianapolis Colts

Round 1 – Pick 16

Omar Cooper Jr.


WR

Indiana

• Jr

• 6’0″

/ 199 lbs

Projected Team

N.Y. Jets

PROSPECT RNK

21st

POSITION RNK

4th

REC

69

REYDS

937

YDS/REC

13.6

TDS

14

Cooper Jr. would be the perfect complement to Garrett Wilson, who has long been asking for a running mate at WR. Yes, the team traded for AD Mitchell, but there’s no guarantee he’ll suddenly morph into a legit No. 2.

Round 1 – Pick 17

Kadyn Proctor


OT

Alabama

• Jr

• 6’7″

/ 352 lbs

Projected Team

Detroit

PROSPECT RNK

4th

POSITION RNK

1st

Leave Penei Sewell on the right, plug Proctor in at left tackle, and move on to the next item on the to-do list.

Round 1 – Pick 18

Peter Woods


DL

Clemson

• Jr

• 6’3″

/ 298 lbs

Projected Team

Minnesota

PROSPECT RNK

19th

POSITION RNK

1st

The Vikings whiffed on Jonathan Allen and Javon Hargrave, and while Peter Woods had a down 2025 season at Clemson, his 2024 tape is top-10 worthy. I’d imagine Brian Flores will have no trouble getting the most out of him.

Round 1 – Pick 19

Kenyon Sadiq


TE

Oregon

• Jr

• 6’3″

/ 241 lbs

Projected Team

Carolina

PROSPECT RNK

24th

POSITION RNK

1st

REC

51

REYDS

560

YDS/REC

11

TDS

8

Sadiq’s 2025 season wasn’t as impressive as his combine workouts, but there’s no denying he’s a physical freak. I also think his best football is ahead of him, and in the right system — and with the right QB — he can flourish. Plus, Bryce Young and the Panthers need to continue adding playmakers.

Round 1 – Pick 20

Treydan Stukes


CB

Arizona

• Sr

• 6’1″

/ 190 lbs

Projected Team

Dallas

PROSPECT RNK

35th

POSITION RNK

6th

The Cowboys get Bain at No. 12, and while Jermod McCoy would seem to be the obvious choice here, I keep hearing that teams are concerned about his knee (McCoy suffered an ACL injury in January 2025 and didn’t play at all last season). Stukes is Brian Branch but faster, and while he played in the slot last season, he has experience outside, at free safety and closer to the line of scrimmage. Draft good players, and Stukes is a really, really good player.

Round 1 – Pick 21

Monroe Freeling


OT

Georgia

• Jr

• 6’7″

/ 315 lbs

Projected Team

Pittsburgh

PROSPECT RNK

25th

POSITION RNK

5th

I think Freeling is a bottom-half-of-Round 1 prospect, and the Steelers could have a need at left tackle, depending on how Broderick Jones bounces back from surgery. Interestingly, there are a lot of similarities between Jones and Freeling — former Georgia players, not a ton of experience and high-end athletes. The question is whether Freeling can make a smoother transition to the NFL than Jones has so far.

Round 1 – Pick 22

Chase Bisontis


IOL

Texas A&M

• Jr

• 6’5″

/ 315 lbs

Projected Team

L.A. Chargers

PROSPECT RNK

39th

POSITION RNK

3rd

I gave serious consideration to going DL here, but after the beating Justin Herbert took last season — not to mention the very real need to find a starting LG — Bisontis is the choice. He’s a 10-year starter at a position that might not be particularly sexy in Round 1, but is definitely important to keeping your franchise QB upright.

Round 1 – Pick 23

Spencer Fano


OT

Utah

• Jr

• 6’6″

/ 311 lbs

Projected Team

Philadelphia

PROSPECT RNK

5th

POSITION RNK

2nd

Man, I really liked Fano’s game at Utah, where he moved to the right side after Caleb Lomu arrived on campus. I’m a bit surprised he’s still available, but that’s just how my board fell. Philly seems like a perfect fit, whether Lane Johnson retires tomorrow or in five years. Fano can be Johnson’s eventual successor and, in the meantime, can play guard, where the Eagles certainly have some needs.

  From

Jacksonville Jaguars

Round 1 – Pick 24

KC Concepcion


WR

Texas A&M

• Jr

• 6’0″

/ 196 lbs

Projected Team

Cleveland

PROSPECT RNK

12th

POSITION RNK

1st

REC

61

REYDS

919

YDS/REC

15.1

TDS

12

Concepcion brings some much-needed juice to the WR room in Cleveland, no matter who ends up under center. He can play inside or out, is a legit return threat and can score from anywhere on the field.

Round 1 – Pick 25

Caleb Banks


DL

Florida

• Sr

• 6’6″

/ 327 lbs

Projected Team

Chicago

PROSPECT RNK

92nd

POSITION RNK

10th

There has been a run on edge rushers, and I think the Bears get more value from bolstering the defensive line over safety at pick No. 25. Either way, this pick will come down to one thing: the medicals. Because when Banks is on the field — and he missed significant time in 2025 — he is just about unstoppable. He reminded us of that at the Senior Bowl, where he had three really impressive practices … and then got hurt again at the combine. A healthy Caleb Banks is one of the best players in the class; concerns about his health, however, could drop him out of Day 1.

Round 1 – Pick 26

Jacob Rodriguez


LB

Texas Tech

• Sr

• 6’1″

/ 231 lbs

Projected Team

Buffalo

PROSPECT RNK

55th

POSITION RNK

6th

The Bills have moved on from the heartbeat of the defense, Matt Milano, and with Rodriguez, the theme continues: not overthinking it. He’s consistently around the ball, generates turnovers and is a high-end athlete with an even higher IQ.

Round 1 – Pick 27

Malachi Lawrence


LB

UCF

• Sr

• 6’4″

/ 253 lbs

Projected Team

San Francisco

PROSPECT RNK

52nd

POSITION RNK

5th

Despite a defensive-heavy draft a year ago, the 49ers still have needs, especially at edge rusher. Former first-rounders Mykel Williams and Nick Bosa are coming off ACL injuries, and behind them are names like Keion White and Sam Okuayinonu. Lawrence, meanwhile, quietly had a dominant season, followed that with a dominant week at the Shrine Bowl, and there’s a good chance he finds his way into Round 1 on Thursday night.

Round 1 – Pick 28

Kayden McDonald


DL

Ohio State

• Jr

• 6’2″

/ 326 lbs

Projected Team

Houston

PROSPECT RNK

32nd

POSITION RNK

3rd

One of the best run defenders in the class, K-Mac still has room to grow as a pass rusher. But here’s the good news: he doesn’t have to be the guy in this Houston defense; ok thahe just needs to do his job on the interior of the defensive line and let his teammates cook. He’s a perfect fit for a unit that has very few needs.

Round 1 – Pick 29

R Mason Thomas


DL

Oklahoma

• Sr

• 6’2″

/ 241 lbs

Projected Team

Kansas City

PROSPECT RNK

37th

POSITION RNK

4th

The Chiefs land Caleb Downs and R Mason Thomas with their two first-rounders, filling two enormous needs on Day 1. Thomas may be undersized (6-foot-2, 242 pounds, 31 5/8-inch arms), but my comp for him is former Sooner Nik Bonitto, who went in Round 2 and is now one of the NFL’s best edge rushers. Not overthinking it here.

  From

Denver Broncos

Round 1 – Pick 30

D’Angelo Ponds


CB

Indiana

• Jr

• 5’9″

/ 182 lbs

Projected Team

Miami

PROSPECT RNK

26th

POSITION RNK

4th

Ponds might have weighed 180 pounds at his pro day, but so did Devon Witherspoon, one of the best young CBs in the league. Ponds plays with that type of athleticism and tenacity, and defensive back is an enormous need for Miami.

Round 1 – Pick 31

Dillon Thieneman


S

Oregon

• Soph

• 6’0″

/ 201 lbs

Projected Team

New England

PROSPECT RNK

47th

POSITION RNK

3rd

Right tackle is an option here, but there’s not an immediate need with veteran Morgan Moses under contract through the ’26 season. But the Pats lost Jaylinn Hawkins in free agency, and while they signed Kevin Byard, it was just a one-year deal. Thieneman made huge strides at Oregon after transferring from Purdue and had one of the most impressive combine workouts in recent memory.

Round 1 – Pick 32

Emmanuel McNeil-Warren


S

Toledo

• Sr

• 6’4″

/ 202 lbs

Projected Team

Seattle

PROSPECT RNK

22nd

POSITION RNK

2nd

I would have loved to target Chase Bisontis here and pencil him in at right guard. And while I like Keylan Rutledge, I don’t like him in Round 1. Instead, after losing Coby Bryant to free agency, McNeil-Warren is the pick. Ty Okada was a pleasant surprise last season, and he has one more year left on his contract, but McNeil-Warren is a ball-hawking center fielder who can also be a thumper in downhill run support.