Nearly seven decades on, Macaya has seen football transform beyond recognition.

He has stated on Pele, Diego Maradona, Lionel Messi and countless more great players.

Television has become digital, statistics have become instantaneous, and World Cups have expanded into global spectacles.

Yet one thing has remained unchanged: Macaya refuses to rush to judgement.

That philosophy shaped his view when Scaloni was unexpectedly appointed Argentina manager in 2018.

“I didn’t have high hopes,” says Macaya, who is a commentator on DSPORTS Radio. “I didn’t know him.”

Scaloni has since led Argentina to Copa America, Finalissima and World Cup glory, turning what many saw as one of football’s biggest gambles into one of its greatest success stories.

Macaya says watching those unfold reinforced something he has believed throughout his career.

“You can’t pass judgement without a much deeper, more complete understanding of the person being judged,” he says.

Lionel Scaloni greeted Macaya during an Argentina press conference in DallasImage source, Getty Images
Image caption,

Scaloni greeted Macaya during Argentina’s news conference in Dallas

Messi or Maradona?

Argentina have once again reached the semi-finals of the World Cup and are preparing to face old foes England on Wednesday (20:00 BST) in a match you can watch live on BBC One and the BBC iPlayer.

Macaya believes Argentina have every chance of repeating their success from 2022.

“Of course they can,” he says. “If we’re talking about what is possible, about the future, I believe Argentina is capable of winning.”

And there is perhaps no surprise when he is asked to name his favourite Argentina player. “Clearly, it’s Messi,” he says.

But when the inevitable question follows – who is the greatest of all time? – the certainty disappears.

“That question deserves a smile,” he says. “There’s no way to measure players throughout history.

“Times have changed. Opponents have changed. Every player is unique. I can say who I personally liked, but that doesn’t mean I believe that player was the best in history.”

It is a response that helps explain why Macaya has remained respected for so long. Rather than definitive rankings, he prefers nuance.

The same applies when he discusses Messi and another brilliant Argentina No 10 – Diego Maradona

“It is very difficult to make a cold comparison,” he says.

“The opponents were different. The needs were different. The support from their team-mates was different. Each had their own life and their own history.”

And he offers a similar answer when asked to compare Pele’s Brazil in 1970 with Maradona’s Argentina in 1986.

“There is no way to compare them,” he says. “The style is completely different.”

‘I’m going to retire at some point’

While it can be easy to bask in the glory of victories, Macaya says defeats matter just as much.

“There are many memorable matches,” he says. “Negative results are also part of that memory.”

For an Argentine, however, World Cup wins naturally occupy a special place.

“Winning the World Cup is my favourite memories, and in Maradona’s case, I think the trophy had finally given him the answer he sought his entire life: to be a world champion,” he says.

As for his own future, after almost 70 years covering the world’s biggest sporting event, retirement is finally on the horizon.

“I’m going to retire at some point,” he says with a laugh.

“I’m retiring now… so I’ll hang up and leave it for another time.”

For someone who has spent a lifetime documenting football history, it would be a fitting way to close a remarkable career.

Though true to his nature, Macaya Marquez’s farewell never feels final.

Related topics

  • Football
  • FIFA World Cup 2026

More on this story

  • When the World Cup finishes, the football continues on BBC Sport
    • Published
      4 days ago
    A composite image of Harry Kane, Erling Haaland and Jude Bellingham
  • Why do Argentina sing about England and the Falklands?
    • Published
      16 hours ago
    Argentina fans cheer their team during the FIFA World Cup 2026 quarterfinal match against Switzerland
  • Messi’s lucky charm? Elfath to ref England v Argentina
    • Published
      15 hours ago
    Ismail Elfath shows a red card to Agustin Canobbio
  • How to watch the World Cup on the BBC and ITV
    • Published
      2 July
    Schedule logo

✔ today silver rate

✔ 2026 winter olympics

✔ chat gtp

✔ silver rate today

✔ silver rate today live

✔ 2030 winter olympics

Read More

Sports

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *